Franchise identity constellation
MLB Franchise Mt. Rushmores
Career VAL multiplied by attributed franchise tenure share, plus a bounded verified-honors bump on that franchise-carried value (Hall of Fame + recorded award wins). Candidates need at least 3 seasons or 40% of their career with the club.
Canonical active-team directory only. International, minor-league, shared-city, and ambiguous raw team keys are excluded rather than guessed. Scores are comparisons inside this sport, not across sports.
Arizona Diamondbacks
Team page →238 contested player-season slots withheld · 21.9% of considered span evidence
#1
Paul Goldschmidt
1B · 2011–2018 · 50% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors110.6
201.1 career VAL · 50% attributed career share · 12 recorded awards
#2HOF 2015
Randy Johnson
P · 1999–2008 · 38% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors100.3
215.9 career VAL · 38% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2015 · 112.27 recorded awards
#3
Luis Gonzalez
LF · 1999–2006 · 44% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors96.0
196.3 career VAL · 44% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
#4
Ketel Marte
2B · 2017–2026 · 83% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors89.8
105.6 career VAL · 83% attributed career share · 1 recorded award
Athletics
Team page →999 contested player-season slots withheld · 25% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1946
Eddie Plank
P · 1901–1914 · 82% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors174.0
188.7 career VAL · 82% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1946
#2HOF 1951
Jimmie Foxx
1B · 1925–1935 · 53% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors172.5
267.1 career VAL · 53% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1951 · 91.2 recorded awards
#3HOF 1993
Reggie Jackson
RF · 1967–1987 · 48% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors165.3
284.5 career VAL · 48% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1993 · 110.62 recorded awards
#4
Bob Johnson
LF · 1933–1942 · 77% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors161.8
191.2 career VAL · 77% attributed career share · 8 recorded awards
Atlanta Braves
Team page →1070 contested player-season slots withheld · 25.4% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1982
Hank Aaron
RF · 1954–1974 · 91% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors426.1
382.5 career VAL · 91% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1982 · 122.83 recorded awards
#2HOF 2018
Chipper Jones
3B · 1993–2012 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors293.3
240.4 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2018 · 108.16 recorded awards
#3HOF 1973
Warren Spahn
P · 1942–1964 · 95% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors278.9
240.6 career VAL · 95% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1973 · 97.89 recorded awards
#4HOF 2015
John Smoltz
P · 1988–2008 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors257.7
211.2 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2015 · 92.88 recorded awards
Baltimore Orioles
Team page →975 contested player-season slots withheld · 24.2% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 2007
Cal Ripken Jr.
SS · 1981–2001 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors276.1
226.3 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2007 · 130.53 recorded awards
#2HOF 1983
Brooks Robinson
3B · 1955–1977 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors231.3
189.6 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1983 · 123.98 recorded awards
#3HOF 1990
Jim Palmer
P · 1965–1984 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors217.2
178 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1990 · 105.57 recorded awards
#4HOF 2003
Eddie Murray
1B · 1977–1996 · 60% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors194.5
265.7 career VAL · 60% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2003 · 100.28 recorded awards
Boston Red Sox
Team page →831 contested player-season slots withheld · 22.4% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1989
Carl Yastrzemski
LF · 1961–1983 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors375.4
307.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1989 · 120.63 recorded awards
#2HOF 1966
Ted Williams
LF · 1939–1960 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors371.7
304.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1966 · 112.38 recorded awards
#3HOF 2009
Jim Rice
LF · 1974–1989 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors251.4
206.1 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2009 · 87.44 recorded awards
#4
Dwight Evans
RF · 1972–1990 · 95% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors241.1
231.4 career VAL · 95% attributed career share · 13 recorded awards
Chicago Cubs
Team page →973 contested player-season slots withheld · 23.6% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1977
Ernie Banks
1B · 1953–1971 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors286.1
234.5 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1977 · 97.81 recorded awards
#2HOF 1987
Billy Williams
OF · 1959–1974 · 88% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors252.5
236.5 career VAL · 88% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1987 · 92.71 recorded awards
#3HOF 1939
Cap Anson
1B · 1876–1897 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors239.8
214.1 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1939
#4HOF 2012
Ron Santo
3B · 1960–1973 · 93% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors226.8
199.2 career VAL · 93% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2012 · 14 recorded awards
Chicago White Sox
Team page →790 contested player-season slots withheld · 22% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 2014
Frank Thomas
DH · 1990–2005 · 83% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors247.9
243.8 career VAL · 83% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2014 · 94.71 recorded awards
#2
Paul Konerko
1B · 1999–2014 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors204.5
185.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
#3HOF 1964
Luke Appling
SS · 1930–1950 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors198.9
163 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1964 · 101.03 recorded awards
#4HOF 1964
Red Faber
P · 1914–1933 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors196.8
175.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1964
Cincinnati Reds
Team page →969 contested player-season slots withheld · 24% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1989
Johnny Bench
C · 1967–1983 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors245.2
201 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1989 · 123.42 recorded awards
#2
Pete Rose
1B · 1963–1986 · 78% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors223.2
259.3 career VAL · 78% attributed career share · 22 recorded awards
#3HOF 2012
Barry Larkin
SS · 1986–2004 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors210.1
172.2 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2012 · 111.39 recorded awards
#4
Joey Votto
1B · 2007–2023 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors208.0
189.1 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 8 recorded awards
Cleveland Guardians
Team page →935 contested player-season slots withheld · 24.3% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1962
Bob Feller
P · 1936–1956 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors213.4
174.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1962 · 101.75 recorded awards
#2HOF 1937
Tristram Speaker
CF · 1916–1926 · 52% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors186.2
291.3 career VAL · 52% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1937 · 83.09 recorded awards
#3HOF 2018
Jim Thome
1B · 1991–2011 · 61% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors173.3
232.4 career VAL · 61% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2018 · 95.81 recorded awards
#4HOF 1975
Earl Averill Sr.
CF · 1929–1939 · 83% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors166.9
164.2 career VAL · 83% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1975 · 6 recorded awards
Colorado Rockies
Team page →283 contested player-season slots withheld · 22.4% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 2024
Todd Helton
1B · 1997–2013 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors257.4
211 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2024 · 91.7 recorded awards
#2
Charlie Blackmon
CF · 2011–2024 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors146.7
133.4 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
#3HOF 2020
Larry Walker
RF · 1995–2004 · 56% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors143.4
209 career VAL · 56% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2020 · 92.57 recorded awards
#4
Carlos González
RF · 2009–2018 · 91% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors120.5
120.5 career VAL · 91% attributed career share · 8 recorded awards
Detroit Tigers
Team page →697 contested player-season slots withheld · 19.2% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1936
Ty Cobb
CF · 1905–1926 · 92% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors404.6
361.8 career VAL · 92% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1936 · 99.23 recorded awards
#2HOF 1980
Al Kaline
RF · 1953–1974 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors329.9
270.4 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1980 · 113.31 recorded awards
#3HOF 1949
Charlie Gehringer
2B · 1924–1942 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors252.1
206.6 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1949 · 92.03 recorded awards
#4HOF 1952
Harry Heilmann
RF · 1914–1929 · 94% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors251.2
219.6 career VAL · 94% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1952 · 86.75 recorded awards
Houston Astros
Team page →468 contested player-season slots withheld · 21.5% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 2017
Jeff Bagwell
1B · 1991–2005 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors269.1
220.6 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2017 · 96.2 recorded awards
#2HOF 2015
Craig Biggio
2B · 1988–2007 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors257.3
210.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2015 · 98.7 recorded awards
#3
Jose Altuve
2B · 2011–2026 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors191.1
173.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 12 recorded awards
#4
Lance Berkman
1B · 1999–2010 · 73% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors142.1
176.2 career VAL · 73% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
Kansas City Royals
Team page →428 contested player-season slots withheld · 21.6% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1999
George Brett
3B · 1973–1993 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors308.9
253.2 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1999 · 116.19 recorded awards
#2
Amos Otis
CF · 1970–1983 · 88% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors159.0
165.2 career VAL · 88% attributed career share · 8 recorded awards
#3
Hal McRae
DH · 1973–1987 · 82% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors143.5
161.3 career VAL · 82% attributed career share · 4 recorded awards
#4
Frank White
2B · 1973–1990 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors142.7
129.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 14 recorded awards
Los Angeles Angels
Team page →494 contested player-season slots withheld · 22% of considered span evidence
#1
Mike Trout
CF · 2011–2026 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors215.3
195.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 16 recorded awards
#2
Tim Salmon
RF · 1992–2006 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors150.6
144.8 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 2 recorded awards
#3
Garret Anderson
LF · 1994–2008 · 88% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors147.5
153.2 career VAL · 88% attributed career share · 5 recorded awards
#4
Chuck Finley
P · 1986–1999 · 82% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors132.2
145.9 career VAL · 82% attributed career share · 5 recorded awards
Los Angeles Dodgers
Team page →926 contested player-season slots withheld · 22.5% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1980
Duke Snider
CF · 1947–1962 · 89% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors236.2
217.8 career VAL · 89% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1980 · 94.49 recorded awards
#2HOF 1998
Don Sutton
P · 1966–1988 · 86% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors233.2
223 career VAL · 86% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1998 · 85.61 recorded awards
#3HOF 1959
Zack Wheat
LF · 1909–1926 · 94% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors220.4
208.4 career VAL · 94% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1959
#4HOF 2022
Gil Hodges
1B · 1943–1961 · 93% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors208.9
183.5 career VAL · 93% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2022 · 11 recorded awards
Miami Marlins
Team page →347 contested player-season slots withheld · 27.4% of considered span evidence
#1
Giancarlo Stanton
DH · 2010–2017 · 57% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors104.7
166.5 career VAL · 57% attributed career share · 7 recorded awards
#2
Mike Lowell
3B · 1999–2005 · 58% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors72.7
113.3 career VAL · 58% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
#3
Derrek Lee
1B · 1998–2003 · 46% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors72.2
142.2 career VAL · 46% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
#4
Luis Castillo
2B · 1996–2005 · 67% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors68.6
93.6 career VAL · 67% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
Minnesota Twins
Team page →731 contested player-season slots withheld · 20.5% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1936
Walter Johnson
P · 1907–1927 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors350.0
286.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1936 · 85.63 recorded awards
#2HOF 1984
Harmon Killebrew
1B · 1954–1974 · 95% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors284.0
245.7 career VAL · 95% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1984 · 95.13 recorded awards
#3HOF 2001
Kirby Puckett
CF · 1984–1995 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors193.7
158.8 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2001 · 104.14 recorded awards
#4HOF 2022
Tony Oliva
RF · 1962–1976 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors186.4
152.8 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2022 · 10 recorded awards
New York Mets
Team page →588 contested player-season slots withheld · 25.6% of considered span evidence
#1
John Franco
P · 1990–2004 · 67% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors158.3
219.9 career VAL · 67% attributed career share · 4 recorded awards
#2
David Wright
3B · 2004–2018 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors157.1
142.8 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 11 recorded awards
#3HOF 1992
Tom Seaver
P · 1967–1983 · 55% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors147.6
219.9 career VAL · 55% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1992 · 114.84 recorded awards
#4
Jerry Koosman
P · 1967–1978 · 63% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors110.3
167.9 career VAL · 63% attributed career share · 2 recorded awards
New York Yankees
Team page →940 contested player-season slots withheld · 25.3% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1974
Mickey Mantle
CF · 1951–1968 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors350.0
286.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1974 · 108.22 recorded awards
#2HOF 1939
Lou Gehrig
1B · 1923–1939 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors329.9
270.4 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1939 · 9 recorded awards
#3HOF 2019
Mariano Rivera
P · 1995–2013 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors312.2
255.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2019 · 113 recorded awards
#4HOF 1936
Babe Ruth
RF · 1920–1934 · 75% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors306.8
335.3 career VAL · 75% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1936 · 98.13 recorded awards
Philadelphia Phillies
Team page →1022 contested player-season slots withheld · 25.2% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1995
Mike Schmidt
3B · 1972–1989 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors316.2
259.2 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1995 · 127.52 recorded awards
#2HOF 1945
Ed Delahanty
LF · 1888–1901 · 88% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors189.4
193.3 career VAL · 88% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1945
#3HOF 1976
Robin Roberts
P · 1948–1961 · 74% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors175.2
194.9 career VAL · 74% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1976 · 93.86 recorded awards
#4HOF 1994
Steve Carlton
P · 1972–1986 · 61% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors166.8
224.6 career VAL · 61% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1994 · 110.82 recorded awards
Pittsburgh Pirates
Team page →908 contested player-season slots withheld · 22.2% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1936
Honus Wagner
SS · 1900–1917 · 86% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors313.5
299.8 career VAL · 86% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1936 · 95.13 recorded awards
#2HOF 1988
Willie Stargell
LF · 1962–1982 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors296.1
242.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1988 · 90.44 recorded awards
#3HOF 1973
Roberto Clemente
RF · 1955–1972 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors266.0
218 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1973 · 117.69 recorded awards
#4HOF 1952
Paul Waner
RF · 1926–1940 · 83% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors198.8
195.5 career VAL · 83% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1952 · 88.33 recorded awards
San Diego Padres
Team page →522 contested player-season slots withheld · 25.7% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 2007
Tony Gwynn
RF · 1982–2001 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors243.8
199.8 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2007 · 124.61 recorded awards
#2HOF 2018
Trevor Hoffman
P · 1993–2008 · 83% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors229.8
226 career VAL · 83% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2018 · 86.86 recorded awards
#3HOF 2001
Dave Winfield
RF · 1973–1980 · 36% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors121.3
273.4 career VAL · 36% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2001 · 109.47 recorded awards
#4
Manny Machado
3B · 2019–2026 · 53% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors93.9
160.1 career VAL · 53% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
San Francisco Giants
Team page →996 contested player-season slots withheld · 24.3% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1979
Willie Mays
CF · 1951–1972 · 91% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors383.5
345.8 career VAL · 91% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1979 · 129.68 recorded awards
#2HOF 1951
Mel Ott
RF · 1926–1947 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors355.4
291.3 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1951 · 99.17 recorded awards
#3HOF 1986
Willie McCovey
1B · 1959–1980 · 90% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors278.2
252 career VAL · 90% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1986 · 89.41 recorded awards
#4
Barry Bonds
LF · 1993–2007 · 67% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors260.6
355.3 career VAL · 67% attributed career share · 41 recorded awards
St. Louis Cardinals
Team page →983 contested player-season slots withheld · 23.8% of considered span evidence
#1HOF 1969
Stan Musial
OF · 1941–1963 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors396.1
324.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1969 · 116.24 recorded awards
#2HOF 1942
Rogers Hornsby
2B · 1915–1933 · 69% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors213.9
255 career VAL · 69% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1942 · 80.11 recorded awards
#3HOF 1981
Bob Gibson
P · 1959–1975 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors211.9
173.7 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1981 · 104.04 recorded awards
#4HOF 1985
Lou Brock
LF · 1964–1979 · 83% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors203.9
200.6 career VAL · 83% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 1985 · 85.75 recorded awards
Tampa Bay Rays
Team page →214 contested player-season slots withheld · 20% of considered span evidence
#1
Evan Longoria
3B · 2008–2017 · 63% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors105.3
153.2 career VAL · 63% attributed career share · 8 recorded awards
#2
Carl Crawford
LF · 2002–2010 · 60% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors80.5
121.9 career VAL · 60% attributed career share · 6 recorded awards
#3
Ben Zobrist
2B · 2006–2014 · 64% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors76.7
112.5 career VAL · 64% attributed career share · 3 recorded awards
#4
Brandon Lowe
2B · 2018–2025 · 89% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors63.9
70.5 career VAL · 89% attributed career share · 1 recorded award
Texas Rangers
Team page →671 contested player-season slots withheld · 28.3% of considered span evidence
#1
Michael Young
SS · 2000–2012 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors142.9
129.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 8 recorded awards
#2HOF 2017
Ivan Rodriguez
C · 1991–2009 · 60% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors126.3
172.5 career VAL · 60% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2017 · 111.02 recorded awards
#3
Juan Gonzalez
RF · 1989–2003 · 64% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors121.6
171.9 career VAL · 64% attributed career share · 11 recorded awards
#4
Toby Harrah
3B · 1969–1986 · 63% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors110.1
163.1 career VAL · 63% attributed career share · 4 recorded awards
Toronto Blue Jays
Team page →396 contested player-season slots withheld · 22.9% of considered span evidence
#1
Carlos Delgado
1B · 1993–2004 · 73% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors155.4
192.6 career VAL · 73% attributed career share · 5 recorded awards
#2
Dave Stieb
P · 1979–1998 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors140.7
127.9 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 7 recorded awards
#3HOF 2019
Roy Halladay
P · 1998–2009 · 73% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors123.0
137.5 career VAL · 73% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2019 · 95.41 recorded awards
#4
José Bautista
RF · 2008–2017 · 82% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors122.0
135.6 career VAL · 82% attributed career share · 9 recorded awards
Washington Nationals
Team page →529 contested player-season slots withheld · 25.4% of considered span evidence
#1
Ryan Zimmerman
3B · 2005–2021 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors153.3
139.4 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 5 recorded awards
#2HOF 2010
Andre Dawson
RF · 1976–1986 · 50% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors143.7
235.5 career VAL · 50% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2010 · 99.9 recorded awards
#3
Steve Rogers
P · 1973–1985 · 100% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors133.3
121.2 career VAL · 100% attributed career share · 5 recorded awards
#4HOF 2003
Gary Carter
C · 1974–1992 · 61% share
VAL + tenure + verified honors131.8
176.8 career VAL · 61% attributed career share · Hall of Fame 2003 · 97.02 recorded awards
Method and source receipt
Career VAL multiplied by attributed franchise tenure share, plus a bounded verified-honors bump on that franchise-carried value (Hall of Fame + recorded award wins). Candidates need at least 3 seasons or 40% of their career with the club.
data/mlb/franchise-careers.jsondata/mlb/val.jsondata/mlb/honors.jsondata/mlb/index.jsondata/mlb/teams.json