Did the Combine Predict Production?
The most-watched pre-draft event, measured against what actually happened. Every combine workout is joined to realized career value, and within each position the correlation is the honest verdict: for quarterbacks and receivers the testing explains almost nothing; only in the trenches does athleticism carry a modest signal.
The verdict, by position
Correlation between the athletic composite and realized career VAL. Higher bars mean the workout tracked production more closely — none of them tracked it strongly.
- TEr 0.27modestn=241
- DLr 0.23weakn=287
- EDGEr 0.19weakn=423
- DBr 0.15weakn=674
- RBr 0.13weakn=412
- LBr 0.05no signaln=422
- WRr 0.01no signaln=485
- QBr -0.07no signaln=149
Production without measurables
Players whose production percentile most exceeded their athletic-testing percentile within their position — the ones the workout would have talked you out of.
- 1Anquan BoldinWR2003athletic 1.8production 99.7· 4.72s forty+97.9pct surplus
- 2Tom BradyQB2000athletic 2.3production 99.7· 5.28s forty+97.4pct surplus
- 3Chad JohnsonWR2001athletic 2.6production 98.7· 4.57s forty+96.1pct surplus
- 4Calais CampbellDE2008athletic 5production 99.9· 5.04s forty+94.9pct surplus
- 5Jarvis LandryWR2014athletic 0.9production 95.2· 4.65s forty+94.3pct surplus
- 6Dre'Mont JonesLB2019athletic 0.1production 94· 5.12s forty+93.9pct surplus
- 7Adrian PetersonRB2002athletic 5.7production 99.6· 4.68s forty+93.9pct surplus
- 8Roy WilliamsS2002athletic 3.6production 95.6· 4.53s forty+92pct surplus
- 9Plaxico BurressWR2000athletic 5.2production 96.7· 4.59s forty+91.5pct surplus
- 10Curtis LoftonMLB2008athletic 0.6production 91.4· 4.79s forty+90.8pct surplus
- 11Pernell McPheeLB2011athletic 2production 92.8· 4.91s forty+90.8pct surplus
- 12Brandon FlowersCB2008athletic 4.3production 94.3· 4.55s forty+90pct surplus
- 13DeAndre HopkinsWR2013athletic 9.8production 99.5· 4.57s forty+89.7pct surplus
- 14Matt RyanQB2008athletic 7.7production 97· 4.89s forty+89.3pct surplus
- 15Danny AmendolaWR2008athletic 3.7production 92.1· 4.58s forty+88.4pct surplus
- 16Bradie JamesILB2003athletic 4.4production 92.1· 4.71s forty+87.7pct surplus
- 17Jurrell CaseyDE2011athletic 3.9production 91.1· 5.04s forty+87.2pct surplus
- 18Randy McMichaelTE2002athletic 6.4production 93.6· 4.88s forty+87.2pct surplus
- 19Danny TrevathanILB2012athletic 3.8production 89.7· 4.84s forty+85.9pct surplus
- 20DeMarcus LawrenceLB2014athletic 13.3production 98.9· 4.80s forty+85.6pct surplus
- 21James ConnerRB2017athletic 9.7production 95.3· 4.65s forty+85.6pct surplus
- 22Jordan PoyerFS2013athletic 9.9production 95.2· 4.54s forty+85.3pct surplus
- 23Tyrann MathieuFS2013athletic 13.3production 98.6· 4.50s forty+85.3pct surplus
- 24Jihad WardLB2016athletic 0.4production 84.2· 5.11s forty+83.8pct surplus
- 25Matt SchaubQB2004athletic 5production 88.3· 5.04s forty+83.3pct surplus
- 26Antonio SmithDE2004athletic 9.5production 92.6· 5.03s forty+83.1pct surplus
- 27Renaldo HillS2001athletic 7.6production 90.6· 4.68s forty+83pct surplus
- 28David MontgomeryRB2019athletic 10.4production 93.3· 4.63s forty+82.9pct surplus
- 29Dwight LoweryFS2008athletic 5.9production 88.6· 4.54s forty+82.7pct surplus
- 30Clark HaggansLB2000athletic 10.3production 93· 4.97s forty+82.7pct surplus
- 31A.J. EpenesaLB2020athletic 3.2production 85.4· 5.04s forty+82.2pct surplus
- 32Jordy NelsonWR2008athletic 15.7production 97.6· 4.51s forty+81.9pct surplus
- 33Randy StarksDE2004athletic 6.7production 88.5· 5.08s forty+81.8pct surplus
- 34Xavien HowardCB2016athletic 12.5production 94· 4.58s forty+81.5pct surplus
- 35Bashaud BreelandCB2014athletic 11.6production 92.7· 4.62s forty+81.1pct surplus
- 36Andra DavisILB2002athletic 9.6production 90.6· 4.77s forty+81pct surplus
- 37Tommy KellyDE2004athletic 6production 86.6· 4.87s forty+80.6pct surplus
- 38Za'Darius SmithDE2015athletic 15.2production 95.2· 4.83s forty+80pct surplus
- 39Kenoy KennedyS2000athletic 0.5production 80.3· 4.71s forty+79.8pct surplus
- 40Larry FooteMLB2002athletic 14.9production 94.2· 4.83s forty+79.3pct surplus
Workout warriors
The honest inverse: players who tested elite but produced below their athletic rank. Every name here carries a real career-value number — a player with no realized value is excluded, never labeled a bust.
- 1Curtis KeatonRB2000athletic 99.2production 2.7· 4.41s forty-96.5pct surplus
- 2Channing TindallLB2022athletic 99.4production 3.9· 4.47s forty-95.5pct surplus
- 3Shemar StewartDE2025athletic 98.9production 7· 4.59s forty-91.9pct surplus
- 4Dorin DickersonTE2010athletic 98.5production 7.3· 4.40s forty-91.2pct surplus
- 5Cam SmithCB2023athletic 94.5production 3.8· 4.43s forty-90.7pct surplus
- 6Shamarko ThomasDB2013athletic 96.9production 6.6· 4.42s forty-90.3pct surplus
- 7Jake FunkRB2021athletic 90.7production 0.5· 4.49s forty-90.2pct surplus
- 8Jermaine BurtonWR2024athletic 94.1production 4.5· 4.45s forty-89.6pct surplus
- 9Leon JoeLB2004athletic 98.5production 8.9· 4.49s forty-89.6pct surplus
- 10Brady CookQB2025athletic 94.3production 5· 4.59s forty-89.3pct surplus
- 11Josh RobinsonDB2012athletic 97.7production 8.8· 4.29s forty-88.9pct surplus
- 12Javin HunterWR2002athletic 90.8production 2.7· 4.47s forty-88.1pct surplus
- 13Tyrion Ingram-DawkinsDT2025athletic 98.8production 12.4· 4.86s forty-86.4pct surplus
- 14Owa OdighizuwaDE2015athletic 88.4production 2.5· 4.62s forty-85.9pct surplus
- 15DJ GiddensRB2025athletic 94.8production 9.2· 4.43s forty-85.6pct surplus
- 16Jabari ZunigaDE2020athletic 86.9production 1.5· 4.64s forty-85.4pct surplus
- 17Logan LeeDT2024athletic 85production 1.4· 5.05s forty-83.6pct surplus
- 18Josh BoyceWR2013athletic 91.3production 8.1· 4.38s forty-83.2pct surplus
- 19Marvin AustinDT2011athletic 94.4production 11.3· 4.84s forty-83.1pct surplus
- 20Devon WylieWR2012athletic 85.5production 2.7· 4.36s forty-82.8pct surplus
- 21Marvell TellCB2019athletic 99.6production 16.9-82.7pct surplus
- 22Ken WebsterDB2019athletic 93.4production 10.8· 4.43s forty-82.6pct surplus
- 23Zaviar GoodenLB2013athletic 96production 13.4· 4.47s forty-82.6pct surplus
- 24Tyler ErvinRB2016athletic 92.7production 10.1· 4.41s forty-82.6pct surplus
- 25Dave StachelskiTE2000athletic 83production 0.4· 4.78s forty-82.6pct surplus
- 26Michael EgnewTE2012athletic 89.4production 6.8· 4.52s forty-82.6pct surplus
- 27Kevin GarrettDB2003athletic 89.8production 7.4· 4.32s forty-82.4pct surplus
- 28Amare BarnoLB2022athletic 94production 11.8· 4.36s forty-82.2pct surplus
- 29Godwin IgwebuikeRB2018athletic 93.6production 11.8· 4.44s forty-81.8pct surplus
- 30Tre TomlinsonCB2023athletic 82.4production 0.8· 4.41s forty-81.6pct surplus
- 31Dri ArcherRB2014athletic 94.5production 13· 4.26s forty-81.5pct surplus
- 32DeAndre ElliottCB2016athletic 81.6production 0.4· 4.55s forty-81.2pct surplus
- 33Tai FeltonWR2025athletic 97production 16· 4.37s forty-81pct surplus
- 34Tanner MuseLB2020athletic 81.3production 0.7· 4.41s forty-80.6pct surplus
- 35Devontez WalkerWR2024athletic 98.2production 17.9· 4.36s forty-80.3pct surplus
- 36Yamon FigursWR2007athletic 80.8production 0.7· 4.30s forty-80.1pct surplus
- 37Carter CoughlinLB2020athletic 89.5production 10.2· 4.57s forty-79.3pct surplus
- 38Tip ReimanTE2024athletic 82production 2.9· 4.64s forty-79.1pct surplus
- 39Randy FasaniQB2002athletic 80.9production 2· 4.77s forty-78.9pct surplus
- 40Trent GambleDB2000athletic 88.3production 9.6· 4.56s forty-78.7pct surplus
Method
Athletic composite = mean of available combine z-scores within position group (40/shuttle/3-cone inverted so higher is always better), joined to realized career VAL. Correlation is the honest per-position verdict on whether the workout predicted production. Players without a VAL career number are excluded, never labeled a bust.
3,093 players across 8position groups have both a combine workout and a realized career-value number. Overall athletic-to-production correlation: r 0.16.
Rankings as of 2026-08-01, as declared by the corpus that produced them.