StatVault
Position Scarcity Index · Original research

Is this a golden era?

For each position and 5-year era, what fraction of active players were historically elite? High percentage = historically abundant talent. Low = a rare scarcity.

Elite = ≥ 85th career percentile KV-H within position group. Coverage: 1999–2025 (nflverse era).

Defensive Back

Peak era: 1999–2003·Drought era: 2024–2025

14%
elite now (2019–)
1999–2003
31%(68/221)
2004–2008
28%(77/274)
2009–2013
24%(82/338)
2014–2018
19%(75/403)
2019–2023
14%(70/505)
2024–2025
11%(44/403)

Pass Rusher

Peak era: 1999–2003·Drought era: 2024–2025

16%
elite now (2019–)
1999–2003
22%(111/507)
2004–2008
20%(104/529)
2009–2013
20%(112/571)
2014–2018
19%(114/603)
2019–2023
16%(89/542)
2024–2025
16%(62/382)

Linebacker

Peak era: 2004–2008·Drought era: 2024–2025

18%
elite now (2019–)
1999–2003
19%(50/262)
2004–2008
21%(54/259)
2009–2013
20%(52/262)
2014–2018
20%(60/300)
2019–2023
18%(70/379)
2024–2025
16%(52/319)

Quarterback

Peak era: 2004–2008·Drought era: 2024–2025

20%
elite now (2019–)
1999–2003
22%(30/134)
2004–2008
24%(32/131)
2009–2013
24%(29/119)
2014–2018
23%(27/116)
2019–2023
20%(24/119)
2024–2025
19%(18/97)

Running Back

Peak era: 2004–2008·Drought era: 2024–2025

17%
elite now (2019–)
1999–2003
16%(47/285)
2004–2008
20%(57/292)
2009–2013
17%(53/304)
2014–2018
18%(54/303)
2019–2023
17%(47/277)
2024–2025
15%(27/181)

Tight End

Peak era: 1999–2003·Drought era: 2024–2025

17%
elite now (2019–)
1999–2003
20%(33/168)
2004–2008
20%(33/166)
2009–2013
17%(35/201)
2014–2018
18%(37/211)
2019–2023
17%(35/210)
2024–2025
16%(24/146)

Wide Receiver

Peak era: 2004–2008·Drought era: 2024–2025

19%
elite now (2019–)
1999–2003
20%(62/304)
2004–2008
22%(64/295)
2009–2013
21%(73/352)
2014–2018
20%(78/386)
2019–2023
19%(72/380)
2024–2025
17%(48/276)

Position Scarcity Index — StatVault original research. Elite threshold: 85th career KV-H percentile within position group. Era coverage begins 1999 (nflverse data start). A player is counted as “active” in an era if any career season falls within that window.