Will McDonald IV is a career quality starter — a pass rusher whose body of work places McDonald in the top quarter of all players at the position historically. The Knox model values sustained contribution over flash, and McDonald's career arc reflects exactly that kind of reliable professional-grade performance.
A high-end edge rusher defined as much by exceptional availability — almost never missed time as by their on-field impact (top 20% all-time). Coaches and teammates could count on them being available.
Worth 78 points of value above a freely-available replacement edge rusher — top 33% of all 4,649 ranked at the position. 3 of 3 seasons cleared the replacement bar, by +26 on average.See board →
Seasons above replacement
Career Value · VORP
78 career value over replacement — #1469 all-time of 4,649. 26/season above a replacement-level EDGE.
Pick #15 (Rd 1) · NYJ · 2023 · +10.1 vs expected KV-H
Fan Rating
Rate Will McDonald IV — All-Time
Explore More
Similar Players
3 seasons × ~26 surplus ≈ VORP 78
Troy Wilson
DE
88% match